A holiday from methadone?

Blog 7 Comments

  • Drug & alcohol recovery

This weeks guest blog is from Russell Webster. Russell blogs on the rapid changes in the way we deliver public services especially in the arena of crime and substance misuse treatment at: www.russellwebster.com/Blog

Mark Gilman has a long history in the drugs field as a practitioner and manager for Lifeline and a regional manager for the National Treatment Agency in the North-East and, currently, the North-West. Despite years at a government quango, he has hung on to his ability to speak plain English. Mark has been an advocate for improved drug treatment for over 20 years now. Unlike many in the drugs field, he sees no contradiction in being a passionate advocate for recovery while still ensuring easy access to the whole range of harm reduction interventions including methadone prescribing.

At his many conference presentations, Mark regularly uses a metaphor comparing providing drug treatment to long-term heroin users with operating a good local travel agency. When the travel agent sees a regular customer come back to book his yearly holiday, he is keen to keep his customer happy but also to suggest other destinations – particularly if they might bring him in a bit more commission:

"Benidorm again this year? Or I’ve got this lovely new resort in Ayia Napa. I think it might suit you even better.”

Similarly, the good drugs worker should welcome back the recently returned drug user and enquire if he wants to go back on his methadone prescription or had he thought about getting off? - especially with all these new recovery-focused services. The drugs worker doesn’t get any more commission (although that might change depending on how far the drugs field adopts payment by results) but, possibly, more job satisfaction.

While Mark Gilman sees methadone as a valid treatment option, the green juice itself provokes strong emotions in active drug users, people in recovery, drug treatment workers, researchers and policymakers.

[quote]

For some it is liquid gold – methadone has allowed them some level of control over their life, gives them stability, the chance to make or mend some meaningful relationships and get or hold down a job. Without methadone, we would have a bigger crime problem and, quite possibly, a lot more people with HIV/AIDS.

Others describe it as a poison, they say that methadone is more addictive than heroin and keeps you trapped in a gilded cage for years. They say it keeps people dependent and denies them the opportunity to change and move on with their lives.

[quote1]

Interestingly, although most drug users and people working in the field have an opinion, there has been little informed debate. Drug and Alcohol Findings recently brought to my attention two research studies which looked at the quality of life for people taking methadone.

The first study, conducted by J. De Maeyer ,W. Vanderplasschen and colleagues, is a systematic review of research on the quality-of-life of opiate users. The review tackles head-on the difficulty in defining what "quality-of-life" is and distinguishes between health-related quality of life and a more subjective appraisal. The paper looked at 38 studies published between 1993 and 2008. Nine of these studies compared the quality of life of drug users taking methadone versus other kinds of substitute prescribing programmes. Measures of health-related quality of life were no different but there were differences in subjective perceptions of the quality of life. Perhaps one of the key findings of the review was that one of the most important reasons given by methadone clients for entering treatment was the desire to improve their satisfaction with life. The motivation to seek help is often not the desire to stop using drugs but to tackle other problems or dissatisfactions in life.

The second study, by the same lead authors, looked at quality-of-life under the influence of methadone via a series of in-depth interviews with 25 individuals who started methadone treatment in the Ghent region of Belgium between 1997 and 2002. The study focused on people who were in and out of treatment with different levels of heroin use. The aim of the study was to identify what constitutes a good quality of life for people who are dependent on opiates and how methadone impacts on this. The interviewees reported that methadone had a powerful positive influence in many areas and an equally strong negative effect in others.

Being on methadone enabled many individuals to maintain relationships and, critically, to continue to care for their children. It also meant that they were able to do something constructive with their time – work, study, hobbies, sport, etc. This in turn helped them to develop higher self-esteem and a more positive self-image. Perhaps most importantly, it enabled them to have a much more meaningful life because there were no longer dominated by the direct consequences of their illegal drug use – such as money problems, spending most of their time getting money for drugs and waiting for dealers or feeling "sick" due to withdrawal symptoms.

On the other hand, there was a clear stigma attached to being on methadone which made it difficult to form some relationships and to integrate into broader society. Methadone dampened down interviewees' emotions and stopped them fully enjoying life (or, of course, experiencing the full extent of negative emotions). Several interviewees regretted that they had substituted one dependency for another; not only was methadone withdrawal a more lengthy process than coming off heroin but they resented being constrained by the requirements of prescribing agencies – especially when these required public daily pick-ups from pharmacies.

For most interviewees a meaningful life involved being free from heroin and substitute drugs, but methadone was seen as a vital first stepping stone. I welcome the way that substance misuse interventions are increasingly based on a proper evidence base.

Nevertheless, I've always thought that effective drug treatment is more art than science – using personality and humanity as well as learnt skills. One of the key attributes of a good drugs worker is surely to work with service users to meet their own goals; to provide the safety and stability that methadone brings whilst encouraging people to consider recovery and to know that there is a lot of help available along the way.

For those who are interested in combining the methadone maintenance and 12-step approaches, there is a new study by Natti Ronel and others: “Can a 12-Step Program working methadone maintenance treatment?" Which describes a combined approach – delivering a 30 session 12-step programme to 32 heroin-addicted individuals in Israel. Beware though, it is behind the Sage Publishing paywall.

The views here are those of the author and not necessarily those of the RSA

Join the discussion

7 Comments

Please login to post a comment or reply

Don't have an account? Click here to register.

  • In the USA it appears more common to be on methadone due to chronic pain, whereas in Belgium the most common reason for dispensing is drug addiction, mainly to heroin. I have searched at sites like findrxonline for methadone and other strong synthetic opiates, and found that the strongest available drugs include hydrocodone/apap, which is actually hard to obtain. Consequently methadone alternatives are not easily obtained elsewhere but in the local clinic or with a doctor's prescription.

  • Some of thepeople who have discussed this post here and elsewhere have commented on the lack of studies/evidence on the experiences of people living with methadone. the Irish Neil Exchange Forum ( http://inef.ie/ ) kindly sent through a study “of the lived experiences of those on methadone maintenance in Dublin North East” ( http://inef.ie/?p=5443) which did include the finding that treatment services were sometimes failing to recognise service users’ desire to be opioid free and that some service users were afraid of remaining on methadone long-term. The study also found a large number of examples of community, family, medical and pharmacy discrimination and prejudice which were hampering peoples’ treatment progress and potential recovery.
    Thanks very much to the INEF for this contribution.

  • Thanks for the kind words Russell. As ever though, its the people in treatment and/or seeking recovery who will make the next move. I wonder if we will see Methadone Anonymous emerging over the next few weeks/months/years.

  • Some of thepeople who have discussed this post here and elsewhere have commented on the lack of studies/evidence on the experiences of people living with methadone. the Irish Neil Exchange Forum (
    http://inef.ie/ ) kindly sent through a study "of the lived experiences of those on methadone maintenance in Dublin North East" (
    http://inef.ie/?p=5443) which did include the finding that treatment services were sometimes failing to recognise service users' desire to be opioid free and that some service users were afraid of remaining on methadone long-term. The study also found a large number of examples of community, family, medical and pharmacy discrimination and prejudice which were hampering peoples' treatment progress and potential recovery.

  • Thanks for the kind words Russell. As ever though, its the people in treatment and/or seeking recovery who will make the next move. I wonder if we will see Methadone Anonymous emerging over the next few weeks/months/years. Also, I wonder if everyone knows about Methadonia the documentary by Michael Negroponte? There are several clips on You Tube and elsewhere http://video.google.com/videop...

Related articles

  • From Rat Park to Housing First

    Rosie Phillips FRSA

    To mark their 20th anniversary, DHI are running The Vision Project. Through a series of articles, podcasts and events during 2019, they are inviting people to contribute their ideas of how society can end social exclusion over the next 20 years. Here is an extract from Rosie’s blog. That can be read in full here

  • How can we give up bad habits for good?

    Ian Burbidge

    With the post-Christmas resolutions looming, when we try to address the worst of our seasonal over-indulgences, the question remains: how can we give up bad habits for good?

  • Using a strength based approach to help combat homelessness

    Sarah Hughes

    Sarah Hughes FRSA, discusses her work with Mayday Trust on finding better ways to work with people going through tough times such as experiencing homelessness, leaving care or coming out of prison.